Missing Service Treatment Records? How Veterans Can Still Support a VA Claim

Legal Services · November 12, 2026

7 min read · 0 comments

Missing Service Treatment Records? How Veterans Can Still Support a VA Claim 7 min

When service treatment records are missing from a VA claims file, the VA must keep trying to obtain them from federal sources until it concludes they do not exist or further efforts would be futile, and it must then notify the veteran. Missing records do not end a claim; the VA has a heightened duty to explain its decision, and veterans can rely on other evidence, such as personnel records, statements from people who served with them, and post-service medical records.

For veterans in Arizona and elsewhere, learning that key records are gone can be discouraging. Understanding what the VA is required to do, and what other evidence counts, can help keep a claim moving.

What Are Service Treatment Records?

Service treatment records, often called STRs, document the medical care a service member received while in the military. They may include entrance and separation exams, sick-call visits, emergency treatment, dental care, and hospital records.
These records often help show the in-service event, injury, or illness that a disability claim depends on. When they are missing, the VA may have difficulty confirming what happened during service, which is why knowing what else can fill the gap matters.

Why Do Service Treatment Records Go Missing?

Records can be absent from a VA file for several reasons, including:

  • Records stored in a different location, such as a military hospital, reserve unit, or National Guard unit
  • Incomplete transfers between military and VA systems
  • Misfiled or misindexed records
  • Records destroyed in the 1973 fire at the National Personnel Records Center in St. Louis

According to the National Archives, that fire destroyed an estimated 16 to 18 million official military personnel files. It affected an estimated 80% of Army records for personnel discharged from November 1912 to January 1960, and an estimated 75% of Air Force records for personnel discharged from September 1947 to January 1964 with names alphabetically after “Hubbard, James E.” Veterans with service in those periods may be more likely to encounter missing records.

What Is the VA Required to Do When Records Are Missing?

The VA’s duty to assist includes specific rules for records held by federal agencies, such as the military. Under 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(c)(2), the VA must make as many requests as necessary to obtain relevant federal records. It may stop only when it concludes the records do not exist or that further efforts would be futile.

Veterans also have a role. The VA may ask for enough information to locate the records, such as the unit, approximate dates, and the condition treated. Providing those details can help the search succeed.

What Notice Must the VA Provide?

If the VA concludes that federal records do not exist or cannot be obtained, 38 C.F.R. § 3.159(e) requires it to notify the veteran. The notice must:

  • Identify the records the VA could not obtain
  • Explain the efforts the VA made to get them
  • Describe what the VA will do next, including that it will decide the claim on the evidence available unless the veteran provides the records
  • State that the veteran is ultimately responsible for providing the evidence
    This notice is an important signal. It indicates that the VA has stopped looking and that alternative evidence will likely carry more weight.

Does a Missing Record Change How the VA Must Decide the Claim?

When service records are lost or destroyed while in government custody, courts have held that the VA has a heightened duty to explain its findings and conclusions and to carefully consider the benefit-of-the-doubt rule. The Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims recognized this in O’Hare v. Derwinski (1991).

That heightened duty has limits. Later decisions explain that it does not lower the legal standard for proving service connection. It increases the VA’s obligation to evaluate and discuss all of the evidence. Courts have also stated that missing records do not create a presumption in favor of either the veteran or the VA.

In practice, this indicates that a veteran with missing records still needs evidence supporting each element of the claim, but the VA must take particular care in how it weighs that evidence and explains its decision.

What Evidence Can Replace Missing Service Treatment Records?

Veterans can often build a strong record without the original STRs. Helpful alternatives may include:

  • Personnel records, which may show assignments, duties, injuries, or profiles limiting physical activity
  • Unit records and morning reports, which may document injuries or hospitalizations
  • Military hospital records stored separately from the main file
  • Statements from people who served with the veteran, describing an injury or event they witnessed
  • Statements from family members about symptoms the veteran reported during or soon after service
  • Letters, emails, or photographs from the time of service that mention an injury or illness
  • Post-service medical records showing treatment soon after discharge
  • The veteran’s own detailed statement describing what happened, when, and where

The National Archives also notes that it uses alternate sources to reconstruct records affected by the 1973 fire, such as VA claims files, state records, pay vouchers, and organizational records.

A Special Rule for Combat Veterans

For veterans who engaged in combat, federal law, 38 U.S.C. § 1154(b), allows the VA to accept satisfactory lay or other evidence of an injury or disease incurred in combat when it is consistent with the circumstances, conditions, or hardships of that service. This can help when records of a combat injury do not exist. Veterans must still show a current disability and a link between that disability and the in-service injury.

What If the VA Never Sent a Notice About Missing Records?

Sometimes a decision mentions that service records were unavailable, but the claims file shows no formal notice describing the VA’s search efforts. That gap may be worth examining. The regulation requires the VA to keep trying federal sources until it concludes the records do not exist or further efforts would be futile, and then to tell the veteran what it tried and what happens next.

If the VA decided the claim without completing those steps, the decision may not reflect everything the VA was required to do. Reviewing the claims file can help show whether proper requests were made and whether the required notice was sent.

How Can Veterans Request Their Own Military Records?

Veterans do not have to rely only on the VA’s search. Many request their own personnel and medical records directly from the National Archives’ National Personnel Records Center, and some find documents that were never added to the VA file. Records from Reserve or National Guard service may also be held by the unit or state, depending on the period of service.

Anything found this way can be submitted to the VA as evidence, along with a short explanation of where it came from.

What Can This Look Like in Practice?

The following is a general illustration, not a prediction about any individual case.

A veteran now living in Arizona injured their back during a field training exercise. They were treated at an aid station, but the VA reports that the service treatment records cannot be located.

To support the claim, the veteran gathers a statement from a fellow service member who helped carry them off the field, letters they wrote home describing the injury, personnel records showing a temporary physical profile, and chiropractic records from the year after discharge. A medical opinion connecting the current back condition to the in-service injury may also help.

Together, these pieces may establish what the missing records would have shown.

What Steps Can Veterans Take Right Away?

  • Read any VA notice about unavailable records carefully, including what the VA says it tried
  • Request personnel records, which may contain information the VA does not have
  • Contact people who served with them who may remember the injury or event
  • Collect post-service treatment records, especially from the first years after discharge
  • Write a detailed personal statement describing the injury, treatment, and symptoms since
  • Keep copies of everything submitted

When Can a Lawyer Help?

Claims with missing records often depend on how alternative evidence is gathered and presented. If the VA denied a claim because the records could not be found, or did not explain how it weighed the evidence, the decision may be worth reviewing.

Veterans in Arizona who want to understand their options can speak with a VA Benefits Lawyer about how missing records affect their claim. A VA accredited attorney or other lawyers for veterans benefits can review the VA’s records notice, assess the alternative evidence, and help identify which review option may fit.

About Southwest Law Firm

Southwest Law Firm is located in Glendale, Arizona, and handles VA disability matters for veterans throughout the state and across the U.S., including rating issues and appeals. Attorney Jay Mendoza, a Marine Corps veteran, holds VA accreditation and is admitted before the Arizona Supreme Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. To reach the office, call (623) 259-5959 or get directions on Google Maps.

Share this entry
SJ

About the writer

Stefani Jeffers

Meet Stefani Jeffers, a dynamic wordsmith dedicated to illuminating various industries through her insightful articles and engaging blogs. With a knack for transforming complex concepts into digestible content, Stefani seamlessly navigates the realms of technology, healthcare, finance, and beyond.

Armed with a degree in Journalism, Stefani merges her passion for storytelling with a commitment to accuracy, delivering content that captivates and informs. Her writing style blends creativity with meticulous research, earning her a reputation as a trusted voice in online publishing.

Beyond her professional pursuits, Stefani is an avid explorer, always seeking inspiration from the world around her. Whether she's uncovering the latest industry trends or immersing herself in literary adventures, Stefani's curiosity knows no bounds.

Join Stefani on her journey as she continues to craft compelling narratives that empower and educate readers across diverse industries.

View all 4,468 articles →